Why does our country suffer so much from obesity? Michael Pollan points out the obvious factors that have brought about this change - we now lead more sedentary lifestyles, and additionally eat diets that are higher in fats and carbohydrates. Further, clever marketing devices trick omnivores into buying more cheap calories found in processed foods. Pollan explains that the central root of the problem, though, is the excess of cheap corn, which accounts for the majority of surplus calories that we intake. Michael Pollan states that we have become masters at "freeing food from nature's limitations and seducing the omnivore into eating more of a single plant than anyone would ever have thought possible" (91) Our creativity on what to do with the mountains upon mountains of corn has given us a cheap and unhealthy source of calories in our diets. As a result of this, we have evolved into industrial eaters, specializing in the consumption of processed foods.
It's true that all of these factors play a role in the rising obesity in our nation - in fact, one in five people in the United States is obese - but Brian Wansink believes that there is more to the equation. How much we eat doesn't depend only on how hungry we are or how good it tastes, but also on the cues around us - the size of the portion, the name on the label, the presentation, or even the lighting in the room. Unfortunately, it is tough to control, or even realize these outside sources are having such a large effect on our intake, hence, "Mindless Eating."
This first chapter really fascinated me. Often, we are preached to about eating smaller portions, leaner meats, and less saturated fat, but rarely do we consider how distant cues may have such profound effects on us. Thinking about my own eating habits, Wansink is definitely correct in his assertions. Back at home, I would fill my dinner plate and that would be it. At Cornell, on the other hand, where every meal is buffet style, it's really difficult to stop myself there. Instead of filling my plate, I fill my tray, and because there's more, I definitely eat more. I think I might try out eating until I'm no longer hungry rather than eating until I'm full. It's true, there is a big difference. I know it won't bring about instantaneous results, but it will make me healthier in the long run. Knowing that this is true, is it possible for me to commit to skimming a few calories off and being healthier all around? The more important question: Is this possible for America's obese population?
Saturday, March 27, 2010
Tuesday, March 9, 2010
Critic in Disguise
This blog post is going to be a bit different than all the others. Rather than discussing prevalent issues or interesting ideas pertaining to the food industry, I will be examining those who examine what we eat when we go out - namely, restaurant critics. The readings for this blog are in preparation for my next essay in which I write a review on Cornell dining hall food.
In "An Appetite for Disguise," Ruth Reichl describes the measures she must take as restaurant critic of The New York Times. If people knew what she looked like, they would surely treat her differently than the rest of the customers, which would not give her an accurate representation of the restaurants she visited. To solve this problem, Reichl decided that she would put on disguises when she ate out - and oddly enough, she really morphed into the people she pretended to be. With each alter-ego, from the "brazen blonde," Chloe, to "frumpy old" Betty, she not only had different appearances, but also different tastes. This doesn't seem possible to me, but if that's how she kept her true identity a secret, all the more power to her.
What this article teaches at its core is that everybody is a potential food critic. This means that restaurants must always put their best effort into their dishes, must always be kind and polite to customers, must always provide the best service they can. It's sad that restaurants feel like they need to convey a better image of their facility when a critique comes to town - why don't they always give forth their best effort? This week when I critique RPCC dining, I am hoping for nothing but the best of service and quality. They don't know I'm a critic, though, so we'll have to see how it goes.
In "An Appetite for Disguise," Ruth Reichl describes the measures she must take as restaurant critic of The New York Times. If people knew what she looked like, they would surely treat her differently than the rest of the customers, which would not give her an accurate representation of the restaurants she visited. To solve this problem, Reichl decided that she would put on disguises when she ate out - and oddly enough, she really morphed into the people she pretended to be. With each alter-ego, from the "brazen blonde," Chloe, to "frumpy old" Betty, she not only had different appearances, but also different tastes. This doesn't seem possible to me, but if that's how she kept her true identity a secret, all the more power to her.
What this article teaches at its core is that everybody is a potential food critic. This means that restaurants must always put their best effort into their dishes, must always be kind and polite to customers, must always provide the best service they can. It's sad that restaurants feel like they need to convey a better image of their facility when a critique comes to town - why don't they always give forth their best effort? This week when I critique RPCC dining, I am hoping for nothing but the best of service and quality. They don't know I'm a critic, though, so we'll have to see how it goes.
Monday, March 8, 2010
The Spread of Superbugs
Today, my dad sent me another article from the New York Times by Nicholas D. Kristof about the use of antibiotics in the food industry. Agricultural businesses vastly overuse antibiotics in the feeding of their animals, leaving human beings vulnerable to disease. The industrial use of antibiotics does serve a purpose - as we learned in Michael Pollan's "The Omnivore's Dilemma," medicating livestock helps them to grow faster. Additionally, cattle are put on an all corn diet - a food which their stomachs cannot properly digest. By adding antibiotics into the mix, the cows do not experience as much pain. In essence, we are drugging up the animals on industrial farms to benefit ourselves - we can produce more and produce it faster.
As we are learning, though, this exploitation of animals can potentially have immense consequences on us as consumers. As the article states, 70 percent of antibiotics in the United States is used to feed healthy animals and 14 percent are used to treat sick livestock. A large majority of our drugs is being pumped into the food business, which is leading to disease that we cannot control. Despite this, Congress and the Obama Administration are refusing to cut down on the use of antibiotics in the raising of livestock. The agricultural industry is far too dependent on these drugs.
True, the resulting cheaper meat is very convenient, but is this worth the toll on human health? With no sign of slowing in the use of antibiotics in the food industry and the consequent resistance to them, is a lethal pandemic inevitable?
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/07/opinion/07kristof.html?emc=eta1
As we are learning, though, this exploitation of animals can potentially have immense consequences on us as consumers. As the article states, 70 percent of antibiotics in the United States is used to feed healthy animals and 14 percent are used to treat sick livestock. A large majority of our drugs is being pumped into the food business, which is leading to disease that we cannot control. Despite this, Congress and the Obama Administration are refusing to cut down on the use of antibiotics in the raising of livestock. The agricultural industry is far too dependent on these drugs.
True, the resulting cheaper meat is very convenient, but is this worth the toll on human health? With no sign of slowing in the use of antibiotics in the food industry and the consequent resistance to them, is a lethal pandemic inevitable?
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/07/opinion/07kristof.html?emc=eta1
America: A Melting Pot of Cuisines
In Sidney Mintz's article about "Eating American," he critically evaluates American habits of consumption. He starts off by stating that there is no such thing as an American cuisine; rather, we all individually choose the foods we wish to incorporate into out diets. Because there is no clear, communal identity of what makes up an American diet, Mintz argues that our nation does not have a cuisine, but instead, a culture surrounding our eating choices.
America is a land of great regional, ethnic, and class differences, and with this comes a very diverse cuisine. Of course, we do have staple foods, such as hamburgers, hot dogs and apple pie. In Mark Weiner's piece entitled "Comsumer Culture and Participatory Democracy: The Story of Coca-Cola During World War II," he describes Coca-cola as a "totem-drink" in American Culture that brings about patriotism and triggers memories. At the same time, others find comfort in parts of the melting pot that is America that remind them of their own homes and ethnicities. An example of this is found in "Best Food Writing 2008" as E. Tai explains how regardless of her American lifestyle, she finds much solace in consuming her ancestors' foods.
America is home to so many people of such different backgrounds that the lines of what exactly constitutes an American diet has been blurred. Surely, when we thing "American" these days, we think of fast food, microwave meals - foods we eat due to immense time constraints and excess hurry. We think of foods high in fat and sugar, a nation of obesity. The point is that what's great about our nation has surely come at a price. Being in a place of such diversity has taken away our ability to form a distinct cuisine for the United States. We are constantly going out to eat - Mexican, Italian, Chinese - but when do we ever go out to eat "American?" Instead, the foods we eat are centered around a collective culture. But I need to ask, what's wrong with that? In other countries, where only a select number of foods are available, the options of what to eat aren't as large. So I guess we have given up a definite American cuisine, but we've done this with the awesome benefit of choice. A melting pot of cuisines. Indian food one day and Thai the next? I have no problem with that.
America is a land of great regional, ethnic, and class differences, and with this comes a very diverse cuisine. Of course, we do have staple foods, such as hamburgers, hot dogs and apple pie. In Mark Weiner's piece entitled "Comsumer Culture and Participatory Democracy: The Story of Coca-Cola During World War II," he describes Coca-cola as a "totem-drink" in American Culture that brings about patriotism and triggers memories. At the same time, others find comfort in parts of the melting pot that is America that remind them of their own homes and ethnicities. An example of this is found in "Best Food Writing 2008" as E. Tai explains how regardless of her American lifestyle, she finds much solace in consuming her ancestors' foods.
America is home to so many people of such different backgrounds that the lines of what exactly constitutes an American diet has been blurred. Surely, when we thing "American" these days, we think of fast food, microwave meals - foods we eat due to immense time constraints and excess hurry. We think of foods high in fat and sugar, a nation of obesity. The point is that what's great about our nation has surely come at a price. Being in a place of such diversity has taken away our ability to form a distinct cuisine for the United States. We are constantly going out to eat - Mexican, Italian, Chinese - but when do we ever go out to eat "American?" Instead, the foods we eat are centered around a collective culture. But I need to ask, what's wrong with that? In other countries, where only a select number of foods are available, the options of what to eat aren't as large. So I guess we have given up a definite American cuisine, but we've done this with the awesome benefit of choice. A melting pot of cuisines. Indian food one day and Thai the next? I have no problem with that.
Thursday, February 25, 2010
GM Foods: The "Magic Bullet"
Wow, speaking of incredibly biased readings... Mike Davis has nothing on Miguel Altieri. In his short book, "Genetic Engineering in Agriculture: The Myths, Environmental Risks, and Alternatives," he completely shuts down the idea of genetically modified foods for the time being. Altieri explores the effects of GM crops on the health of people, crops and animals, the welfare of farmers, and the upkeep of thousands of ecosystems, and basically concludes that we'd be better off without GM foods.
Altieri talks about how biotechnology companies are merely making false promises pertaining to the effects of genetically engineered crops. This innovation in technology is NOT a "magic bullet," and cannot reduce our dependence on pesticides, reduce environmental problems, or even solve world hunger. GM foods are NOT "substantially equivalent" to standard crops, and the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) research on these foods is not adequate enough to start stocking our shelves with them. Also, we have plunged into making these genetically modified foods without fully investigating short and long term effects that they will have on us and the world around us. In essence, we are the rats in a giant experiment, testing these foods before its even entirely positive if they are safe. This is not fair to us, and there are many alternatives available - so why even consider genetically engineered foods?
Even more so, Altieri talks about how these technological innovations are profit driven rather than created for the good of mankind and our ecosystems. As a result, we cannot expect GM foods to truly benefit us, or solve problems with foods scarcity in other nations. Altieri states, "The real thrust of the genetic engineering industry is not to make agriculture more productive, but rather to generate profits" (5). I view this take as WAY too cynical - sure, profit is always a consideration in making choices, but that doesn't mean that decisions can't also be made to help others.
I really found this book to be interesting, but I do not agree with Altieri's close-minded attack on GM foods. Sure, he considers both sides of the debate, but writes the benefits off almost immediately. Now that I've read his take, I feel like I should read up on the other side that is pro-GM foods. I agree that more research should be conducted, but GM foods could potentially help us out in so many different ways. I'm sure we could use alternatives, but the idea of a "magic bullet" just seems too good to pass up.
Altieri talks about how biotechnology companies are merely making false promises pertaining to the effects of genetically engineered crops. This innovation in technology is NOT a "magic bullet," and cannot reduce our dependence on pesticides, reduce environmental problems, or even solve world hunger. GM foods are NOT "substantially equivalent" to standard crops, and the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) research on these foods is not adequate enough to start stocking our shelves with them. Also, we have plunged into making these genetically modified foods without fully investigating short and long term effects that they will have on us and the world around us. In essence, we are the rats in a giant experiment, testing these foods before its even entirely positive if they are safe. This is not fair to us, and there are many alternatives available - so why even consider genetically engineered foods?
Even more so, Altieri talks about how these technological innovations are profit driven rather than created for the good of mankind and our ecosystems. As a result, we cannot expect GM foods to truly benefit us, or solve problems with foods scarcity in other nations. Altieri states, "The real thrust of the genetic engineering industry is not to make agriculture more productive, but rather to generate profits" (5). I view this take as WAY too cynical - sure, profit is always a consideration in making choices, but that doesn't mean that decisions can't also be made to help others.
I really found this book to be interesting, but I do not agree with Altieri's close-minded attack on GM foods. Sure, he considers both sides of the debate, but writes the benefits off almost immediately. Now that I've read his take, I feel like I should read up on the other side that is pro-GM foods. I agree that more research should be conducted, but GM foods could potentially help us out in so many different ways. I'm sure we could use alternatives, but the idea of a "magic bullet" just seems too good to pass up.
Monday, February 22, 2010
Factory Farming Causes Spread of Disease
In "The Triangle of Doom" by Christopher Olsen and "The swine flu crisis lays bare the meat industry's monstrous power" by Mike Davis, conditions of mass production of meat are shown to have widespread effects on our health. More specifically, the conditions on feedlots are conducive to the spread of diseases, such as H1N1. "Old fashioned pig pens" have been transformed into industrial animal farms in order to maximize production. The result is a high density of highly packed animals, exchanging sicknesses due to weakened immune systems. In fact, the crowding of animals has brought about a "continual cycling of viruses," which resulted in catastrophic events for both animals and humans.
Terrible impacts of industrialization in pork and poultry markets reached an all-time high during the Livestock Revolution, during which "the (global) share of mean and milk consumed in developing countries rose from 37 to 53 percent and 34 to 44 percent, respectively from 1983 to 1997." Corporate production has greatly been influenced by the urbanization and high demands of human population, and our need for these animals has created the necessary conditions for viral spread and infection. After all, the chance of disease spreading is far greater on a farm with 5,000 pigs than on a farm of the same size with only 100 pigs. If we realized how factory farming is so bad for humans and animals alike, wouldn't we just change our ways? With demand at such a high level, is this ideal even possible?
Terrible impacts of industrialization in pork and poultry markets reached an all-time high during the Livestock Revolution, during which "the (global) share of mean and milk consumed in developing countries rose from 37 to 53 percent and 34 to 44 percent, respectively from 1983 to 1997." Corporate production has greatly been influenced by the urbanization and high demands of human population, and our need for these animals has created the necessary conditions for viral spread and infection. After all, the chance of disease spreading is far greater on a farm with 5,000 pigs than on a farm of the same size with only 100 pigs. If we realized how factory farming is so bad for humans and animals alike, wouldn't we just change our ways? With demand at such a high level, is this ideal even possible?
Friday, February 19, 2010
Not Grass Fed, But At Least Pain-Free
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/19/opinion/19shriver.html?emc=eta1
My dad, who has been keeping up with my blog, sent me a fascinating article today regarding the pain of animals on feedlots. With an increasing population and American demand at more than 100 pounds of red meat per person per year , it looks as though there is no end in sight to mass production in the meat industry. For greater efficiency, cattle on feedlots are barely given any room to graze and are fed corn instead of grass at the expense of their comfort. Although there is no solution at present to changing these factory farms, scientists are beginning to look into ways to reduce the discomfort of animals.
Recently, neuroscientists have gathered new information regarding how animals process pain. There are two separate pathways for perceiving this pain in the brain, and scientists believe that by damaging one of these cortexes, they can also eliminate the pain that an animal feels. Even more incredible, scientists are beginning to discover how to genetically engineer animals in such a way where they lack proteins that allow them to feel this pain in the first place. Although experiments on pain have only been conducted on mice at this point, neuroscientists doubt the results will be much different if performed on cattle or chickens.
Now the question is: Is this innovation a good idea? Is it ethical to take away pain that animals feel just so that we can exploit them without guilt? Or is it just to free them of pain if we're going to continue our consuming ways? Will this change exacerbate our over-consuming ways?
My dad, who has been keeping up with my blog, sent me a fascinating article today regarding the pain of animals on feedlots. With an increasing population and American demand at more than 100 pounds of red meat per person per year , it looks as though there is no end in sight to mass production in the meat industry. For greater efficiency, cattle on feedlots are barely given any room to graze and are fed corn instead of grass at the expense of their comfort. Although there is no solution at present to changing these factory farms, scientists are beginning to look into ways to reduce the discomfort of animals.
Recently, neuroscientists have gathered new information regarding how animals process pain. There are two separate pathways for perceiving this pain in the brain, and scientists believe that by damaging one of these cortexes, they can also eliminate the pain that an animal feels. Even more incredible, scientists are beginning to discover how to genetically engineer animals in such a way where they lack proteins that allow them to feel this pain in the first place. Although experiments on pain have only been conducted on mice at this point, neuroscientists doubt the results will be much different if performed on cattle or chickens.
Now the question is: Is this innovation a good idea? Is it ethical to take away pain that animals feel just so that we can exploit them without guilt? Or is it just to free them of pain if we're going to continue our consuming ways? Will this change exacerbate our over-consuming ways?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)